Runnymede
Medieval History

Runnymede

King John, Magna Carta, and the Failed Peace That Became the Rule of Law

By Shane Larson

$4.99Paperback $18.99

About This Book

On 25 November 1215 a clerk of the royal chancery copied a writ onto the close roll. It ordered the justiciar, Hubert de Burgh, to send to Rochester at all speed forty of the fattest pigs. The king's miners had tunnelled under the south-east corner of the castle keep and propped the roof with timber. The pig fat was to burn the props through, and within days a quarter of the great tower had fallen into the ditch. The garrison, which had held the castle for the rebel barons for seven weeks, surrendered at the end of the month.

Five months earlier the same king had put his seal to a charter in a meadow beside the Thames, granting those same barons that he would take no scutage without the common counsel of the realm, that no free man would be imprisoned except by the lawful judgement of his peers, and that twenty-five of them might seize his castles if he broke his word. The pigs are what became of it.

A Peace Treaty That Did Not Keep the Peace

Runnymede: King John, Magna Carta, and the Failed Peace That Became the Rule of Law tells the story of that charter in the order it happened. It begins with the reign that produced the crisis. John lost Normandy in 1204 and became the first king since the Conquest who had to live in England and govern it in person. He sold heirs their inheritances at prices no one could pay and used the debts to keep them obedient, fought the pope for six years over who should be archbishop of Canterbury, and in 1214 watched the alliance he had financed to win Normandy back broken at Bouvines in an afternoon.

The second part is the meadow: who the rebels were and what each of them owed the king, the fall of London in May 1215, the days of bargaining between Windsor and Staines, and a walk through the document as a reader of 1215 would have grouped it. The charter is about 3,500 words of Latin with no clause numbers, and most of it concerns inheritance fees, wardship, widows, debts, sheriffs, fish weirs, the measures for wine and cloth, and the royal forest. Clause 39 sits in the middle, unemphasised. Clause 61, the committee of twenty-five with the power to make war on the king, sits at the end, and it is the reason the peace could not hold.

The third part is the war that most accounts of Magna Carta skip: the pope's annulment, Rochester, the French prince received in London, John's death at Newark, and the battle in the streets of Lincoln that decided whether England would have a Capetian king. The charter outlived all this because the men who won the war needed something to offer the losers, and they reissued it in the boy king's name with the dangerous clauses cut. In 1225 the young king issued it a third time in return for a tax, and that text is the one that became law. The fourth part follows the law into its second life, from the statute roll of 1297 to Sir Edward Coke, William Penn, the Fifth Amendment and the memorial American lawyers built above the meadow in 1957, and says at every turn which story is which.

Why I Wrote This

I had just finished The Absent King, and Richard's death leaves the empire to a brother who loses most of it within five years, so John was simply the next thing. What I did not expect was the document. I had the usual idea of Magna Carta, a founding charter of liberty, and I had never read it. When I did, I found a clause ordering fish weirs out of the Thames and a clause fixing the width of dyed cloth, in the same hand as the clause about free men, and I found that the whole thing had been annulled by the pope ten weeks after it was sealed. The gap between what the barons wrote and what has been said about it since seemed to me the real subject, and the only honest way to handle it was to tell both halves and keep them apart.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to read Twice a Queen or The Absent King before this book?

No. The three books share a family and a few dates, but each stands on its own. Eleanor's and Richard's parts are given a paragraph each here with a pointer to the book that tells them in full. This one begins in April 1199, the week Richard died.

Did Magna Carta really fail?

The 1215 charter did. Neither side kept its terms, the pope declared it null on 24 August, about ten weeks after it was sealed, and England was at war by the autumn. What survived was a reissue, cut down in 1216 and 1217 and granted again in 1225 in exchange for a tax, and it is that text that entered the statute book.

What does Magna Carta actually say?

Mostly things about money and land: inheritance fees, wardship, widows' dower, debts, the summoning of a council before a scutage, the courts, sheriffs, fish weirs, standard measures, the forest, and an enforcement committee of twenty-five barons. Chapter Seven walks through all of it in the book's own words, and Appendix A gives every clause with what happened to it in each reissue.

Is this a legal history or a narrative history, and how long is it?

Two-thirds narrative, one-third history of an idea, about 74,000 words in thirteen chapters and four parts with three appendices. Parts One to Three tell the reign, the meadow and the war, with the witness named in every scene. Part Four follows the document through Coke, the colonies and the Supreme Court.

Does the book cover the American side of Magna Carta?

At full length. Chapter Thirteen runs from William Penn's 1687 printing through the Stamp Act argument, the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments and the 1957 American Bar Association memorial at Runnymede, and the Introduction tells how the Lincoln Cathedral copy spent the Second World War in a vault at Fort Knox.

If You Liked This, You Might Like

  • The Absent King — Richard's ten years end at Châlus with the empire intact; this book begins the same week and watches his brother lose it.
  • Twice a Queen — Eleanor of Aquitaine rode for John in 1199 and died at Fontevraud weeks before Rouen fell; her book is where the empire John inherited was made.
  • The Hundred Years' War — Gascony, the one province the fifteenth of 1225 paid to keep, is what Edward III went to war for in 1337.
  • The Norman Conquest — the cross-Channel kingdom John lost in 1204 was 138 years old, and this is where it was made.

What the barons got was a failed peace; what everyone since has had is the use of it.

A standalone on the medieval shelf, following The Absent King.

What You'll Learn

  • **Arthur of Brittany,** who went into his uncle's custody at Falaise in 1202 and was never seen again: the three accounts of his death, their distance from the event, and what the barons of Anjou believed.
  • **The Braose affair,** in which a king's favourite became a debtor, fled, and left his wife and eldest son to starve in a royal castle; John's own published explanation set beside the chroniclers' versions.
  • **The rolls.** From 1199 the chancery kept copies of its outgoing letters, which makes John's the first reign in English history that can be watched day by day.
  • **Sixty-three clauses in plain English,** paraphrased from the Latin rather than from any copyrighted translation, with what a baron would have understood by free man, peers and the law of the land.
  • **Clauses 10 and 11,** the provisions on debts to Jewish lenders, explained from the crown's practice of taking over those bonds and foreclosing on the barons who owed them.
  • **Three appendices:** every clause of 1215 with its fate in 1216, 1217 and 1225; who was who, including the twenty-five barons of clause 61; and a timeline with a key to every surviving exemplar and where to see it.
Get the book
Runnymede
$4.99Paperback $18.99

More in This Genre

View all →
New
When Adam Delved
When Adam Delved
Wat Tyler, John Ball, and the English Peasants' Revolt of 1381
New
The King in the Marshes
The King in the Marshes
Alfred the Great and the Viking War for England
New
The Wars of the Roses
The Wars of the Roses
Lancaster, York, and the Thirty-Two Years That Ended Medieval England
New
The Enterprise of England
The Enterprise of England
Philip II, the Spanish Armada, and the Wrecks on the Irish Coast